
If you work for a leader who mostly prefers to work alone, all you usually see of them is their closed office door or busy status. Then, when you get their time or attention, they seem indifferent to the problems you’re facing. They might bluntly tell you to figure it out yourself, which is probably how they fix their own problems. There’s little to no sense of collaboration across your team.
This type of distant, uncommunicative behavior is what Hogan calls Reserved. At its core, Reserved behavior at work is a preference for independence that, under pressure, turns into withdrawal from the team.
Characteristics of Reserved Leaders
The Hogan assessments measure three aspects of personality: the bright side (everyday personality), the dark side (potential derailers), and the inside (motives and values). The Hogan Development Survey (HDS) describes derailers in 11 assessment scales, each of which concerns a particular pattern of behavior. Reserved is one of them. These behaviors are strengths on a day-to-day basis, but they can become counterproductive during derailment. Derailment occurs when an individual stops self-monitoring in times of stress, pressure, complacency, or boredom.
At their best, people with high Reserved scores tend to remain steady during crises, handle criticism well, and enjoy working independently. In derailment, they may seem aloof, uncommunicative, unaware of office politics, and indifferent to others’ feelings.
Reserved leaders might not notice if team morale is low. From the outside, the Reserved derailer can look like introversion, but introversion is about where people get their energy, whereas Reserved behavior is about withdrawal. A recognizable example is Ron Swanson from Parks and Recreation. Tough under pressure, Swanson also keeps his office door shut, avoids small talk, and tends to guard his private life.
An Expert Perspective on the Reserved Derailer
In this video, Tony Cao, PhD, explains how Reserved behavior at work can affect team productivity, engagement, and trust.
When Reserved Behavior Becomes a Problem
Reserved behavior in a leader becomes a workplace liability when it begins to affect team dynamics. Independence—and expecting team members to show independence—contributes to an environment of accountability. But when the leader isn’t accessible to team members regularly, independence turns into isolation. Leaders who respond to stress and pressure by distancing themselves from their teams may find that team members often feel disconnected.
Leaders who score high on the Reserved scale may seem detached and limit close relationships. This can jeopardize the team’s psychological safety because team members may be less likely to raise concerns or ask for help. A Reserved leader might care about their team members yet still fail to build interpersonal connections with them. A tendency to focus on tasks rather than people can give an impression of toughness and insensitivity.
These behaviors can have negative consequences for a leader’s reputation. Executives could notice low engagement and low productivity on the leader’s team. Peers may stop asking to collaborate after enough rebuffs. And team members whose leader is unavailable when needed might leave without ever saying why.
How to Manage Reserved Behavior at Work
Leaders with higher Reserved scores tend to assume that good work speaks for itself, so they rarely acknowledge it. Yet they also depend on a productive, engaged team, and engagement is hard to sustain when people don’t know if their efforts are noticed. Reserved leaders should make a deliberate habit of recognizing their team’s work, whether in person or in writing.
Another way to mitigate Reserved tendencies is to rely on others for what the leader might miss. A socially attuned peer or team member can keep them informed about team morale and workplace dynamics, so the leader knows when to step in personally.
Reserved leaders can share development goals with a trusted colleague who can help flag moments when independence reads as aloofness. Identifying their own triggers for derailment allows leaders to arrange reasonable workarounds. If one trigger is a dread of long check-ins, for instance, leaders can schedule shorter, more frequent meetings instead.
A leader who keeps their Reserved derailer in balance can use their natural independence to serve their team. They understand the advantages and disadvantages of maintaining distance and can strategically adapt when necessary.
Expert Contributor
Originally published at https://www.hoganassessments.com/blog/how-independence-becomes-problem-reserved-behavior-at-work/